Skip to content

Territory 5 · AI governance

Evaluating AI Tools for CIRO Compliance

How to evaluate AI tools for CIRO compliance. Covers shadow AI risk, a four-criteria framework, data handling questions, and what approved tools look like.

Updated 4 min read
An instrument maker’s hands setting a small offset on a brass dial.

Chapter 5: AI/Technology & Documentation

Technology can improve documentation quality and efficiency. It can also create compliance risk if implemented without proper evaluation. CIRO described (external site, opens in a new tab) "the relationship between technologies used in the investment ecosystem and managing their risks to protect investors" as a key theme of its Compliance Report for 2025 (external site, opens in a new tab) (Administrative Bulletin 25-0035, released 31 January 2025). CIRO's Compliance Report for 2026 (external site, opens in a new tab) (Administrative Bulletin 26-0034, released 17 February 2026) adds a section on AI in dealers' operations.

5.1 The Shadow AI Reality

Many advisors are already using AI tools through personal accounts. ChatGPT for drafting emails. Otter.ai for transcribing meetings. Various tools for summarizing notes or generating content.

These tools, when used outside firm-approved channels, create what is called "shadow AI." The productivity gains are real. The compliance implications are also real.

The 2025 Compliance Report (external site, opens in a new tab) says of social media: "We identified cases where dealers' controls over employees' social media accounts used for business purposes were inadequate." In those cases, the Report says, dealers lacked adequate policies and procedures to identify relevant employee social media use, and no controls were in place to detect, approve, or monitor it.

The passage is about social media. Northern Catalyst's reading is that the same holds for AI tools: if client information flows through unapproved channels, documentation and data handling requirements may not be met. On AI itself, the 2026 Compliance Report (external site, opens in a new tab) says: "As part of our FinOps examination approach, we will be enquiring about the use of AI in dealers' operations. To the extent dealers are using AI, we will be reviewing the operational controls they implemented to ensure AI is working as designed."

5.2 Tool Evaluation Framework

Before using any AI tool for documentation purposes, evaluate it against four criteria:

A tool that cannot answer these questions clearly is probably not ready for use with client information.

5.3 Data Handling Questions

For any AI documentation tool, clarify:

  • Is client-identifying information removed before data leaves your device?
  • Where does AI processing occur (your device, Canadian servers, US servers, elsewhere)?
  • Is your data used to train the AI model?
  • What certifications does the vendor hold (SOC 2, ISO 27001)?
  • Can you obtain documentation suitable for your compliance team?

Cross-border data flows are a particular concern under Canadian privacy legislation. If client PII is transmitted to servers outside Canada, additional considerations apply under PIPEDA and Quebec Law 25.

5.4 What "Approved" Looks Like

AI tools that firms approve for advisor documentation typically share characteristics:

  • The firm can say what client information leaves the device, where it is processed, and under what agreement
  • The advisor retains control over what data is processed
  • Retention policies are clear and documented
  • The vendor provides documentation suitable for compliance review

When evaluating any tool, the test is whether it can answer the four criteria above clearly and with documentation your compliance team can review.

At the end of the path

Compliance Conversation Kit

Free. The material for the conversation with the compliance officer.

This is educational content based on published regulatory sources as at the page's last-updated date. It is not legal, compliance, or financial advice. Review specific compliance decisions with your compliance officer and qualified legal counsel before implementation.

Source: Joint CSA/CIRO Staff Notice 31-368 · 10 December 2025

Re-verified